The cryptocurrency market has been eagerly awaiting the approval of a spot Bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Bitcoin ETF is a type of exchange-traded fund that tracks the price of bitcoin, the most popular cryptocurrency in the world. Bitcoin ETF allows investors to gain exposure to bitcoin without having to buy, store, or manage the digital asset themselves. Bitcoin ETF also provides more liquidity, transparency, and regulatory oversight than other bitcoin-related products.
A Bitcoin ETF works by holding a certain amount of bitcoin in a trust or a custodian, and issuing shares that represent a fraction of the bitcoin holdings. The shares are traded on a stock exchange, just like any other ETF. The price of the shares reflects the market value of the bitcoin holdings, minus the fees and expenses of the fund. The fund manager is responsible for ensuring that the shares are backed by enough bitcoin, and for rebalancing the portfolio as needed.
A spot Bitcoin ETF would allow investors to buy and sell shares of a fund that holds actual bitcoins, rather than futures contracts or other derivatives. However, the SEC has repeatedly delayed its decision on several spot Bitcoin ETF proposals, citing concerns about market manipulation, fraud, custody, and investor protection.
Tekedia Mini-MBA edition 16 (Feb 10 – May 3, 2025) opens registrations; register today for early bird discounts.
Tekedia AI in Business Masterclass opens registrations here.
Join Tekedia Capital Syndicate and invest in Africa’s finest startups here.
One of the main challenges for a spot Bitcoin ETF is to prove that the underlying market is free from manipulation and has sufficient liquidity and transparency. The SEC has expressed doubts about the reliability and integrity of the price discovery mechanisms in the cryptocurrency market, especially in unregulated or lightly regulated venues. The SEC also worries that a spot Bitcoin ETF could create arbitrage opportunities for market participants who have access to different platforms or sources of information.
To address these issues, a spot Bitcoin ETF would need to demonstrate that it has robust policies and procedures to monitor and prevent market manipulation, and that it sources its prices from reputable and regulated exchanges or indices. Additionally, a spot Bitcoin ETF would need to show that it has adequate liquidity providers and market makers to ensure efficient trading and fair pricing of its shares.
Another major hurdle for a spot Bitcoin ETF is to ensure the security and safety of the bitcoins that it holds on behalf of its investors. The SEC has raised concerns about the risk of theft, loss, or hacking of the digital assets, as well as the potential for fraud or misappropriation by the fund’s custodian or manager. The SEC also questions the ability of a spot Bitcoin ETF to verify the ownership and existence of its bitcoins, and to comply with anti-money laundering (AML) and know-your-customer (KYC) regulations.
To overcome these challenges, a spot Bitcoin ETF would need to provide evidence that it has a qualified and trustworthy custodian that can safeguard its bitcoins in accordance with high standards of security and compliance. Moreover, a spot Bitcoin ETF would need to establish clear and enforceable rules and agreements regarding the custody, transfer, and redemption of its bitcoins, and to conduct regular audits and inspections of its holdings.
The SEC is concerned about the suitability and appropriateness of a spot Bitcoin ETF for retail investors, who may not fully understand the risks and complexities involved in investing in cryptocurrencies. The SEC fears that a spot Bitcoin ETF could expose investors to excessive volatility, liquidity risk, operational risk, legal risk, and regulatory risk. The SEC also worries that investors could be misled by false or misleading information or advertising about the performance or benefits of a spot Bitcoin ETF.
To mitigate these risks, a spot Bitcoin ETF would need to provide clear and comprehensive disclosures about the nature, characteristics, and risks of investing in cryptocurrencies and in the fund itself. A spot Bitcoin ETF would also need to educate investors about the differences between a spot Bitcoin ETF and other types of crypto-related products, such as futures-based ETFs or trusts. Furthermore, a spot Bitcoin ETF would need to adhere to strict standards of governance, accountability, and transparency in its operations and reporting.
The main benefit of Bitcoin ETF is that it lowers the barriers to entry for investors who want to participate in the bitcoin market. Investors do not need to worry about setting up a digital wallet, dealing with complex security protocols, or facing hacking or theft risks. They also do not need to deal with the tax implications of buying and selling bitcoin directly. Instead, they can simply buy and sell shares of Bitcoin ETF through their brokerage accounts and enjoy the same tax treatment as other ETFs.
Another benefit of Bitcoin ETF is that it increases the legitimacy and adoption of bitcoin as an asset class. By being listed on a regulated stock exchange, Bitcoin ETF attracts more institutional and retail investors, as well as more media attention and public awareness. This can boost the demand and liquidity for bitcoin, and potentially drive up its price. Moreover, Bitcoin ETF can help reduce the volatility and manipulation of the bitcoin market, by providing more accurate price discovery and reducing the influence of unregulated platforms.