I recently read about a lady who feared being left out of the AI trend, so she introduced it into her work. She would use AI to write captions and write advertising copies to send to the graphics designer. She even started incorporating AI to reply to client inquiries and emails.
What was the result?
A crash in engagements. She noticed that since she took this route, her post engagements and leads were significantly reduced.
Tekedia Mini-MBA edition 16 (Feb 10 – May 3, 2025) opens registrations; register today for early bird discounts.
Tekedia AI in Business Masterclass opens registrations here.
Join Tekedia Capital Syndicate and invest in Africa’s finest startups here.
The question is, what did she do wrong? Wasn’t the AI supposed to do the job faster and better?
Well, while there are predictions that AI may take over jobs in several industries, I have yet to see any that adds the creative industry to that list. In recent years, artificial intelligence (AI) has made significant strides in various fields, including creative industries such as art, music, and writing. AI tools and algorithms have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in generating content, assisting artists, and streamlining creative processes.
However, inherent risks are associated with over-reliance on AI, especially in creative work. One of the pitfalls is that it can harm the quality, authenticity, and diversity of creative output. When people interact with creative works, they want to feel and connect to the human behind the work, and if you over-rely on AI, they miss out on that.
How Relying Too Heavily on AI can impact work output
1. Lack of Originality: AI algorithms are trained on existing datasets and patterns, which means they work well with mathematical-based tasks, but when it comes to creativity, they may produce content that lacks originality and uniqueness. Over-reliance on AI-generated content can lead to a homogenization of creative output, where everything starts to look or sound the same, devoid of the human touch and individual expression, kind of like a monotone that is lacking in emotions.
2. Loss of Authenticity: Creative work is often valued for its authenticity and emotional resonance. AI-generated content may lack the depth, nuance, and emotional authenticity that come from human experience and perspective. This can result in a disconnection between the creator and the audience, leading to a loss of engagement and impact. And this is what I think might have happened with the lady we referenced earlier.
3. Dependency on Technology: Relying too heavily on AI tools and automation can lead creatives to rely overly on algorithms to generate ideas, solve problems, and make creative decisions. This can limit the development of critical thinking skills, intuition, and creative problem-solving abilities in humans, especially for entry-level employees.
4. Ethical Concerns: AI algorithms are not immune to biases and ethical issues, which can manifest in the content they produce. Over-reliance on AI in creative work may perpetuate harmful stereotypes, reinforce existing inequalities, and marginalize certain societal voices and perspectives. This is often a general concern with anything driven by technology.
How Over-reliance on AI May Stifle Human Creativity and Innovation
1. Loss of Creative Control: When creatives rely too heavily on AI tools and automation, they may relinquish control over the creative process, losing autonomy and ownership over their work. Creativity thrives on freedom and experimentation, and excessive automation can constrain creative expression and exploration.
2. Reduction of Serendipity: Serendipity plays a crucial role in the creative process, leading to unexpected discoveries, breakthroughs, and innovations. AI algorithms operate based on predefined parameters and data, which may limit their ability to produce genuinely novel and surprising outcomes. Over-reliance on AI can diminish the serendipitous moments that often lead to creative insights and new ideas.
3. Diminished Human Connection: Creativity is a profoundly human endeavor fueled by emotions, experiences, and interpersonal connections. Excessive reliance on AI may erode the human element of creative work, leading to a loss of connection between creators and their audiences. Human creativity thrives on empathy, collaboration, and shared experiences, which AI algorithms cannot fully replicate.
4. Stagnation of Skills: Creativity is a skill that improves with practice, experimentation, and learning from failure. When creatives rely too heavily on AI tools and automation, they may become complacent and fail to develop their creative abilities to their full potential. This can lead to a stagnation of skills and a lack of innovation in the long run. This situation could be worse for those who enter the space in these times when AI is already dominating the flow.
Where lies the balance?
Do creatives discard AI then and stick to the old way of doing things? No.
The balance lies in collaboration. Instead of viewing AI as a replacement for human creativity, embrace it as a tool for collaboration and augmentation. AI can complement human creativity by assisting with repetitive tasks, generating ideas, and providing inspiration. Collaborative approaches combining AI’s strengths and human creativity can lead to richer, more innovative outcomes.
There is also a need to encourage creativity, especially the younger ones, to cultivate essential skills such as critical thinking, problem-solving, curiosity, and adaptability. Investing in creativity training and development programs can help individuals harness their creative potential and overcome the limitations of AI.
We should also not forget to maintain human oversight and intervention in the creative process to ensure that AI-generated content aligns with the creator’s vision, values, and ethical standards. Creatives should retain control over critical, creative decisions while leveraging AI tools to enhance productivity and efficiency.
By finding the right balance between AI assistance and human creativity, we can unlock the full potential of both to create truly impactful and meaningful creative work. Whether in your business, job, or other pursuits, there is a place for AI to assist you in working smarter.Find it and explore it.