The past week has seen a lackluster performance of crypto products, with no significant inflows or outflows recorded. According to a report by CoinShares, the total assets under management (AUM) of crypto products remained at $62.7 billion, a slight decrease from the previous week’s $63.3 billion.
One of the main factors behind this stagnation is the continuous decline of GBTC’s AUM, which dropped by $1.4 billion in the past week. GBTC, or Grayscale Bitcoin Trust, is the largest and most popular crypto product, holding about 75% of the market share. However, GBTC has been suffering from a persistent discount to its net asset value (NAV), meaning that its shares are trading below the value of its underlying assets.
The discount, which reached a record high of 21.23% on March 4, has deterred investors from buying GBTC shares, as they would be paying more for less exposure to Bitcoin. Moreover, some investors have been selling their GBTC shares to arbitrage the price difference, adding more downward pressure on the product.
Tekedia Mini-MBA edition 16 (Feb 10 – May 3, 2025) opens registrations; register today for early bird discounts.
Tekedia AI in Business Masterclass opens registrations here.
Join Tekedia Capital Syndicate and invest in Africa’s finest startups here.
The discount is partly attributed to the lock-up period of GBTC shares, which requires investors to hold them for six months before they can sell them on the secondary market. This creates a mismatch between supply and demand, as new investors are reluctant to buy GBTC shares at a premium, while existing investors are eager to sell them at a discount.
Another factor that contributes to the discount is the increasing competition from other crypto products, especially exchange-traded funds (ETFs). In the past few months, several Bitcoin ETFs have been launched in Canada and Brazil, offering investors a more convenient and cost-effective way to access the crypto market. These ETFs have lower fees than GBTC and trade at or near their NAV, making them more attractive alternatives.
The report by CoinShares suggests that some of the outflows from GBTC may have been redirected to these ETFs, as they have seen inflows of $49 million in the past week. The report also notes that there is a strong demand for a Bitcoin ETF in the US, as evidenced by the recent filings by several firms, including Fidelity and VanEck.
However, the approval of a Bitcoin ETF in the US is still uncertain, as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has repeatedly rejected or delayed such proposals in the past. The SEC has expressed concerns about the volatility, liquidity, custody and manipulation of the crypto market, and has asked for more regulation and oversight before it can greenlight a crypto product.
Therefore, GBTC may still have a chance to regain its dominance in the crypto product space, if it can address its discount issue and improve its value proposition. One possible solution is to convert GBTC into an ETF, which would eliminate the lock-up period and align its price with its NAV. However, this would require approval from the SEC, which may not be forthcoming anytime soon.
Another possible solution is to reduce GBTC’s management fee, which is currently 2%, much higher than the average fee of 0.5% for crypto ETFs. This would make GBTC more competitive and appealing to investors who are looking for lower costs and higher returns.
In any case, GBTC’s performance will have a significant impact on the overall crypto product market, as it represents a large portion of the investor demand and sentiment. If GBTC can overcome its challenges and regain its attractiveness, it may spark a new wave of inflows and growth for the crypto product sector.