The prediction that Bitcoin spot ETFs will surpass Gold ETFs during a Trump presidency has been discussed by Nate Geraci, president of The ETF Store. This forecast is based on several factors including the growing acceptance and institutional interest in Bitcoin, coupled with potential policy shifts under a Trump administration that could favor cryptocurrencies.
Geraci’s prediction is supported by the rapid growth in assets under management for Bitcoin ETFs, which have seen significant inflows since their introduction in early 2024, with some reports indicating they’ve already reached or surpassed key thresholds when compared to gold ETFs.
For instance, it was reported that the iShares Bitcoin ETF had already surpassed the asset size of the iShares Gold Trust by November 2024. This trend is seen as a reflection of Bitcoin’s increasing integration into mainstream finance, buoyed by a pro-crypto policy agenda from Trump, which includes plans for regulatory changes and the establishment of a strategic Bitcoin reserve.
Tekedia Mini-MBA edition 16 (Feb 10 – May 3, 2025) opens registrations; register today for early bird discounts.
Tekedia AI in Business Masterclass opens registrations here.
Join Tekedia Capital Syndicate and invest in Africa’s finest startups here.
However, it’s important to approach this prediction with caution as market dynamics can be influenced by numerous variables including regulatory changes, macroeconomic conditions, and shifts in investor sentiment. The comparison between Bitcoin and gold as investment vehicles also hinges on their perceived roles as hedges against inflation or economic instability, where traditionally gold has been favored, but Bitcoin is increasingly seen in a similar light, especially with its fixed supply cap.
The context of Trump’s previous administration and his public stance on cryptocurrencies, particularly Bitcoin, suggests a potentially more crypto-friendly regulatory environment, which could indeed propel Bitcoin ETFs ahead of gold ETFs in asset size. However, this is speculative, and while the ETF Store president’s insights are based on recent trends and potential policy directions, the actual outcome would depend on a myriad of factors including how the administration navigates the complex landscape of financial regulation and economic policy.
Donald Trump’s approach to cryptocurrency regulation during his presidency has shown a significant evolution from skepticism to a more supportive stance. Here’s an overview based on available information:
Skepticism to Support: Initially, during his first term, Trump was critical of cryptocurrencies, describing Bitcoin as “based on thin air” in 2018 and later as a “scam” in 2021, expressing concerns over their volatility and potential for facilitating illegal activities. However, leading up to and following his re-election campaign, Trump has positioned himself as a pro-crypto candidate, promising to make the United States the “crypto capital of the planet.” This includes pledges to create a strategic national Bitcoin reserve and to establish a “bitcoin and crypto presidential advisory council.”
Regulatory Promises: Trump has advocated for regulatory clarity, aiming to reduce the ambiguity that has been seen as a hindrance to private sector innovation. He promised to fire SEC Chairman Gary Gensler, seen as an adversary by the crypto industry due to his aggressive regulatory approach, and to appoint a more crypto-friendly SEC chair.
There’s an expectation that under Trump, the regulation of digital assets might shift from the SEC to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), which some in the industry believe would be less stringent. This shift could potentially clarify the regulatory status of cryptocurrencies, defining them more clearly as commodities rather than securities.
Industry Expectations: The crypto industry has responded positively to these promises, with Bitcoin reaching new highs post-election, reflecting optimism about a more favorable regulatory environment. There’s an anticipation of less enforcement action against crypto companies and more focus on rulemaking that would facilitate mainstream adoption of cryptocurrencies. Industry leaders are in communication with Trump’s transition team to influence policy and personnel decisions, aiming for a regulatory framework that supports innovation while providing necessary investor protections.
Potential Risks and Criticisms: Critics worry that a lax regulatory environment might increase risks of fraud and market manipulation, potentially leading to another financial crisis or enabling extremist groups to use cryptocurrencies for nefarious purposes. There’s also concern about how much Trump’s personal financial interests in cryptocurrencies might influence policy, potentially leading to conflicts of interest.
While Trump has expressed intentions to foster a more crypto-friendly regulatory environment, the exact policies and their implementation would depend on legislative cooperation, regulatory appointments, and the broader economic context. The industry and investors are closely watching these developments, expecting a shift that could significantly impact the crypto landscape.